I have just finished recovering data from two failed Maxtor drives. One is a customer’s PC, the other one’s mine.
I bought my customer a Western Digital, as Microbytes were short on Seagate drives, and Western Digital is pretty reliable as far as I am concerned, as I only needed to replace 3, compared to 10+ Maxtor drives. As I mentionned in an earlier post, they were pretty adamant about me trying to save their backed-up data, and the fact that I didn’t feel like going through another windows installation, so I set out to attempt a Norton Ghost clone. I have used Norton Ghost in the past, to clone my dad’s drive last summer when it failed (yes, it was a Maxtor). I tried the latest Norton, version 10, and I didn’t like it much, so I reverted to the 2003 bootable floppy. I really don’t know what the hell they did to version 10, but it seems like the interface was so bloated and dumbed-down that even I could not understand it. Finally I found an option that allows me to run the old version of it, which I am familiar with, but I reverted to the previous version because the boot CD took about 15 minutes to load somekind of a Windows kernel that reboots every 24 hours.
Anyway, I pop in the Ghost 2003 boot floppy and boot up the machine. It did not work, so I enabled the “Forces to continue cloning even if source contains bad clusters.” option, started the cloning and went to bed. The next morning a “Cloning successful” message appears. I turn off the machine and pop out the old Maxtor, and it starts up normally. I run a scandisk just to see if everything is good, and it seems pretty good.
As for my drive, things were a little more difficult, due to errors in reading the Master File Table. So, I try a couple of times, and it ended up seeing the drive instead of closing. I enable the same option to continue cloning even if there are bad clusters. I wake up at night and decide to check out the progress, and I find a message informing me that the MFT is corrupt. Yes I know, so it continues. The next morning, it still ain’t finished, so I go back to bed. Then when I woke up again around noon, the cloning was complete. In disbelief, I put it in my comp. Windows recognizes it, asks to reboot and perforns a CHKDISK to clean up the file table. It reboots, and I find out that most of my data was safe. So that means I will be shipping that drive back to Maxtor today.
So, if you need to clone an ailing drive, Norton Ghost is the tool. Obviously, it’s not a replacement for a backup!
unhandledexception.net